Newswire

For Further Information Contact:

ukscotland@transatlanticlaw.com

UK: Email outage and commercial litigation

Friday’s global Microsoft outage left many businesses, including law firms, without reliable access to email and services. 

For commercial litigation, where court deadlines are strict and documents are lodged and exchanged electronically, this raises a critical question: what happens if a deadline is missed? 

An initial instinct may be to panic when our inboxes freeze, however, in today’s technology-reliant world, the courts tend to take a pragmatic approach acknowledging that technological errors are often outwith human control. 

Courts will make allowances for genuine failures, but they expect parties to act promptly, be proactive and keep evidence.

The Scottish position: “mistake, oversight or other excusable cause”

A party who misses a procedural step relies on the court’s general power to grant “relief”, meaning to excuse the failure and allow the case to continue. In the Court of Session, the rules (rule 2.1 of the Rules of the Court of Session 1994) allow the court to relieve a party from the consequences of failing to comply where that failure is “shown to be due to mistake, oversight or other excusable cause”, on such conditions as it thinks fit. 

Sheriffs in the Sheriff Courts have the same power (rule 2.1 of the Ordinary Cause Rules 1993, and rule 2.1 of the Sheriff Appeal Court Rules 2021 in the Sheriff Appeal Court). The rules make clear that relief is available only where the party shows one of those three grounds. The burden is on the party in default to explain what went wrong.

The Microsoft outage may well be seen as an ‘other excusable cause’, but relief is not automatic and a missed deadline may require further procedural steps in order to restore the case. While on occasion the parties may be able to agree a practical way forward without involving the court (e.g. they may informally agree to extend a date for exchanging documents), in theory the party in default must apply to the court by motion asking it to exercise its rule 2.1 power. The motion must be intimated to the other parties, who can oppose it, and it should explain exactly what went wrong, and what was done about it. It should be backed by evidence, such as screenshots of outage notices or bounce-back messages, and where possible, the document that should have been lodged is lodged at the same time. 

If decree has already been granted against a party because it failed to respond in time, the route in the sheriff court is different. The party must lodge a reponing note under rule 8.1 of the Ordinary Cause Rules, setting out its proposed defence and explaining its failure to appear. In every case, the court has a discretion. 

The issues when it comes to email outages and lodging deadlines may be resolved by the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service increasing reliance on the Civil Online platform. Although no technology is error proof. These court rules are in place to protect parties’ positions when either human or technological errors occur.

The English approach: relief from sanctions

In England and Wales, the equivalent question is governed by “relief from sanctions”. That is, relief from a penalty imposed for breaching a rule or court order.  

If you miss a court deadline, you will need to submit an application to court for relief from sanctions under CPR 3.9. When deciding whether to grant relief, the English courts will apply the three-stage test set out in Denton v TH White Ltd [2014] EWCA Civ 906: how serious or significant was the breach, why did it happen, and what do all the circumstances of the case require? A technology failure will not automatically constitute a justification for the missed deadline under that test; instead, the court will look at the whole picture, including how promptly the party acted.

When the court’s own systems fail

Recent outages have affected the courts as well as law firms. It may be that court business is slower than usual in the coming weeks, as court staff work through any backlog of emails, enquiries and hearings caused by the Microsoft outage. 

Practical lessons 

A party seeking relief after a technology-related default should be ready to show exactly what failed and when; evidence of the failure; that the cause was outside its control rather than ordinary oversight; and that it acted promptly once the problem came to light.

The outage on Friday 13 November is a reminder that technology has changed how litigation is run, but not the fundamentals. Deadlines and procedure matter. Evidence matters. At Burness Paull, our Disputes & Regulatory team combines detailed knowledge of both Scottish and English court procedure with a practical, forward-thinking approach to technology. 

By Burness Paull LLP, Scotland, a Transatlantic Law International Affiliated Firm.  

For further information or for any assistance please contact ukscotland@transatlanticlaw.com

Disclaimer: Transatlantic Law International Limited is a UK registered limited liability company providing international business and legal solutions through its own resources and the expertise of over 105 affiliated independent law firms in over 95 countries worldwide. This article is for background information only and provided in the context of the applicable law when published and does not constitute legal advice and cannot be relied on as such for any matter. Legal advice may be provided subject to the retention of Transatlantic Law International Limited’s services and its governing terms and conditions of service. Transatlantic Law International Limited, based at 84 Brook Street, London W1K 5EH, United Kingdom, is registered with Companies House, Reg Nr. 361484, with its registered address at 83 Cambridge Street, London SW1V 4PS, United Kingdom.